Introduction
Construction has changed a lot with the use of Building Information Modeling (BIM). BIM helps design and build projects in a smarter way by making teamwork easier and using data more effectively. One of the biggest advantages of BIM is clash detection process that finds and fixes issues between different building parts before construction starts. In big projects, different teams—like architects, structural engineers, and MEP (mechanical, electrical, and plumbing) experts—work together. If they don’t coordinate properly, parts of the building might clash, causing delays, extra costs, and wasted effort. Clash detection helps avoid these problems by spotting conflicts early so they can be fixed before construction begins.
In this blog, we’ll dive into clash detection in BIM—why it’s important, the different types, benefits, tools, challenges, processes and best ways to use it effectively.
What is Clash Detection in BIM?
Hard Clash
A hard clash occurs when two or more building components physically occupy the same space. For example, if a structural column passes through an HVAC duct, it creates a conflict that must be resolved. BIM tools like Autodesk Navisworks, Solibri, and BIM 360 detect these issues by comparing 3D models of different disciplines. Resolving hard clashes often involves redesigning or repositioning elements to avoid conflicts.
Soft Clash
Soft clashes, also known as clearance clashes, happen when elements do not physically intersect but violate spatial tolerances or safety requirements. For instance, an air conditioning unit may be too close to a ceiling or wall, limiting maintenance access. Soft clashes are crucial for ensuring that operational and safety standards are met, and they help optimize the functionality of building systems.
Workflow Clash
A workflow clash is not a physical interference but a scheduling or sequencing conflict in the construction process. These clashes occur when tasks are scheduled in a way that causes delays or inefficiencies. For example, if electrical wiring installation is scheduled after drywalling, rework may be required, leading to increased costs. BIM-based 4D simulations, which integrate time with 3D models, help detect and resolve workflow clashes, ensuring smoother project execution.
The Importance of Clash Detection in BIM
Clash detection plays a crucial role in improving project coordination, reducing costs, enhancing quality, and ensuring timely project completion. Let’s explore some of its key benefits in detail:
1. Cost Savings
One of the biggest benefits of Clash Detection is saving money. In construction, projects often go over budget because of unexpected problems, like needing to redesign or make changes. By catching clashes early in the design phase, we can fix issues before construction begins. This helps avoid costly delays and the need for rework.
For example, if we find a problem between HVAC ducts and structural beams during design, we can fix it by changing the design or materials before it becomes an issue on-site.
2. Time Efficiency
Clash Detection helps save time by catching problems early, so the construction process runs more smoothly. When problems are fixed during the design phase, there’s less need to stop work on-site to solve issues, which means faster project completion.
For example, if a clash between plumbing and electrical systems is found after construction begins, it could cause a lot of delays. With Clash Detection, we can find the problem early, make quick fixes, and keep the project on schedule.
3. Improved Collaboration and Communication
Clash Detection encourages teamwork between different groups (architects, engineers, and other professionals). By finding issues early, these teams can work together to solve them. This makes communication better and helps prevent misunderstandings during the project.
For instance, architects can talk to engineers about changing structural plans to make space for mechanical systems, avoiding problems later on.
4. Enhanced Quality Control
Clash Detection also helps with quality control. It ensures the design will meet the required standards and that systems will work properly. By fixing clashes in advance, we can make the design more efficient, safe, and high performing. It also helps spot errors that could be missed otherwise, reducing the chance of faulty installations and delays.
5. Risk Mitigation
Unexpected design problems can create safety risks, compliance issues, and costly downtime. Using Clash Detection lets us spot potential dangers early, like structural weaknesses or unsafe working conditions. It helps reduce risks related to building safety and system performance, ensuring everything meets regulations and is safe for workers and occupants.
Process of Clash Detection in BIM
The process of clash detection involves several key steps that help streamline the workflow and minimize costly errors during construction. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the process:
Step 1: Creating a Comprehensive Model
The first and most important step in the clash detection process is creating a comprehensive, integrated 3D model. This model must include all relevant disciplines for the project, such as:
- Architecture: The layout, space planning, and design elements, such as walls, floors, windows, doors, and finishes.
- Structural Engineering: Structural elements like beams, columns, foundations, and load-bearing walls.
- MEP Systems: This includes the design and layout of mechanical systems (HVAC), electrical systems (lighting, wiring, panels), and plumbing systems (pipes, drains, fixtures).
- Other Systems: Depending on the project, other specialized systems might need to be integrated, such as fire protection, security systems, or telecommunications.
A complete, well-constructed model allows all disciplines to be visualized in a unified way, ensuring that there is a comprehensive understanding of how each system interacts with others. This holistic view makes it much easier to identify potential clashes or issues, which could otherwise be missed in a fragmented approach. A comprehensive model is the foundation for efficient clash detection, as it ensures that all components of the design are considered from the outset.
Step 2: Running Clash Detection Software
After the comprehensive 3D model has been created, the next step is to run it through Clash Detection software. This software is designed to identify conflicts, clashes, or interferences between the various systems within the model. Commonly used software for clash detection includes:
- Autodesk Navisworks: Known for its ability to perform comprehensive clash detection and simulation, Navisworks can scan the 3D models of all disciplines and identify clashes quickly.
- Solibri Office: A powerful tool for quality assurance, Solibri can detect clashes and perform code compliance checks to ensure that the design adheres to building regulations.
- Revit: While primarily a BIM modeling tool, Revit also includes features for clash detection, particularly when models from different disciplines are integrated.
- Revizto: Revizto is a cloud-based coordination platform that makes it easy for teams to view models, track clashes, and assign issues in real time. It brings designers, engineers, and contractors together in one place, making collaboration smoother and more efficient. It also works well with tools like Revit and Navisworks.
The Clash Detection software scans the model for geometry, spatial conflicts, and relationships between different systems. For instance, if an HVAC duct runs through a structural beam or plumbing pipes interfere with electrical wiring, the software flags these issues as clashes. The software generates a detailed list or visual report that highlights the exact locations of the clashes, making it easier for the team to address them efficiently.
Step 3: Review and Resolution
Once the software has detected potential clashes, the next step is to review and resolve these issues. The review process often involves:
- Visualization: The identified clashes are visualized in a 3D environment to gain a clear understanding of where the conflicts are occurring and the severity of each issue. This helps stakeholders from different disciplines (e.g., architects, engineers, contractors) to see the problem firsthand.
- Prioritization: Not all clashes are equal in terms of impact on the project. Some may have a significant effect on the project’s timeline or budget, while others might be relatively minor. The team must prioritize which issues to resolve first based on factors like severity, the ease of resolution, and the potential impact on construction.
- Collaboration: The design teams, including architects, engineers, and MEP specialists, work together to propose solutions for the clashes. This may involve making adjustments to the design, such as rerouting pipes or ducts, moving walls, or changing the location of electrical fixtures. The goal is to find solutions that ensure all systems are coordinated and can function properly together.
This step is critical to avoid costly delays or errors during construction. Effective communication and collaboration between all disciplines are key to resolving clashes in a way that maintains the integrity and functionality of the overall design.
Step 4: Coordination Meetings and Communication
Regular coordination meetings are an essential part of the clash detection process. These meetings allow the various project stakeholders—such as architects, engineers, MEP specialists, contractors, and project managers—to discuss the identified clashes, evaluate potential solutions, and agree on the necessary adjustments to the design. Key elements of the coordination meetings include:
- Clash review: The team reviews the identified clashes, evaluates their impact on the project, and discusses the best course of action.
- Solution agreement: All parties involved agree on the proposed solutions and adjustments to the design. These discussions ensure that everyone understands the impact of each change and is aligned on the path forward.
- Scheduling and timelines: Coordination meetings also help in planning the timeline for resolving clashes, making sure that any changes are implemented within the project’s deadlines.
Effective communication during these meetings is critical to ensure that all stakeholders are on the same page and that clashes are resolved as efficiently as possible. In the case of complex projects, these meetings may need to be held frequently to monitor progress and address any emerging issues.
Step 5: Re-running Clash Detection
Once the design team has made adjustments to the model to resolve the clashes, it is essential to re-run the clash detection process to ensure that the issues have been fully addressed. This is an iterative process, and the steps involved include:
- Re-checking the model: After the design changes are made, the updated model is run through the clash detection software again to ensure that no new clashes have been introduced and that the previous issues have been successfully resolved.
- Continuous refinement: This process may need to be repeated multiple times, particularly for larger or more complex projects. Each iteration helps fine-tune the design and ensures that the final model is free of clashes and ready for construction.
- Final verification: Once the model passes the clash detection process without any issues, it can be considered clash-free, and the project can move forward with confidence. The final model serves as a reliable reference for all stakeholders during the construction phase.
This iterative process of running clash detection, reviewing, resolving, and re-running the analysis is essential to ensure that the project’s design is optimized for constructability and that there are no conflicts that could lead to delays or cost overruns during construction.
Looking for Clash Detection Services to Mitigtate Construction Risks?
Get in touch with BIMPRO LLC for clash detection services at +1 (346) 508-6588 or email us at info@bimprous.com
BIM Software for Clash Detection
Several BIM software tools specialize in clash detection, each offering unique features to cater to different project needs. Here’s a breakdown of some of the popular tools used for clash detection in BIM:
Autodesk Navisworks
Autodesk Navisworks is a powerful tool commonly used for large construction projects. It allows professionals to combine different building models—like architectural, structural, and MEP (Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing)—into one unified 3D model. This makes it easier to spot clashes between these systems early in the design process. The software includes a feature called Clash Detective, which automatically checks for conflicts and helps resolve them before construction begins. It’s perfect for projects that involve multiple models and complex coordination, ensuring that everything fits together properly in the real world.
Revit
Revit is another popular BIM tool, particularly favored by architects, engineers, and construction professionals. Unlike other software, Revit allows for real-time clash detection, meaning any issues in the design can be spotted and addressed as the model is being built. This makes it a great tool for continuous coordination between different teams working on the same project. Revit’s integration of various building systems like architecture, structure, and MEP helps ensure that all elements are aligned, making it easier to detect and fix potential issues right away.
Solibri Office
Solibri Office is known for its ability to perform detailed quality checks and clash detection in BIM models. It uses a rule-based system, allowing users to set specific guidelines for detecting clashes or errors in the design. This means it can check not only for visual clashes but also for issues related to building codes or safety regulations. Solibri’s automated detection system helps ensure that any problems are found early, and its reporting features allow for easy communication of the issues to the project team. It’s an excellent tool for ensuring overall project quality and compliance with regulations.
Tekla BIMsight
Tekla BIMsight is a simple yet effective clash detection tool, especially useful for structural and MEP systems. It allows different models to be combined into one platform, making it easy to detect any potential issues between these systems. The software is designed to be user-friendly, so it’s accessible even for teams that may not have advanced technical skills. Tekla also promotes collaboration by allowing team members to share models and detect clashes together. It’s an ideal choice for projects focusing on the structural and MEP aspects of a building or infrastructure.
Bentley Navigator
Bentley Navigator is tailored for large infrastructure projects like roads, bridges, and utilities. It focuses on ensuring that all components of these complex systems fit together seamlessly before construction begins. Bentley Navigator offers tools for clash detection and project coordination, allowing stakeholders to work together to find and fix any potential issues in the design. It’s especially beneficial for large-scale infrastructure projects that require a high level of detail and collaboration between different teams. With its focus on infrastructure, it helps ensure that everything works as planned from start to finish.
Revizto
Revizto is a user-friendly, cloud-based tool that helps teams spot and fix clashes in building models. What makes it special is how it brings everyone—architects, engineers, contractors—into one shared workspace where they can view models, talk about issues, and keep track of what’s been resolved. It works with both 3D and 2D views, so it’s easy for anyone to jump in and understand what’s going on. One of the biggest strengths of Revizto is how well it connects the design team with the construction team, helping them stay on the same page throughout the project. It also works smoothly with other tools like Revit and Navisworks, which makes it a great choice for keeping coordination simple and efficient.
Best Practices for Clash Detection in BIM
Clash detection in BIM is a key step to ensure that different parts of a building design work well together. It helps catch problems early so they can be fixed before construction starts, saving time and money. Here are some simple tips to make clash detection more effective:
1. Start Early in the Design Process
The earlier you start checking for clashes, the better. Begin clash detection as soon as the first designs or models are available, ideally during the early planning stages. Finding problems early helps you fix them before construction begins, preventing costly delays and mistakes down the line.
2. Review the Design Regularly
Clash detection should not just happen once—it should be a regular part of the process. As the design develops and changes, you need to keep checking for new clashes. This ongoing review ensures that as the project evolves, any new issues are caught and dealt with right away.
3. Work Together as a Team
Clash detection works best when everyone involved in the project is part of the process. Architects, engineers, contractors, and subcontractors should all be on the same page. Working together ensures that everyone sees potential issues from their own area of expertise and can quickly find solutions to problems.
4. Focus on the Most Important Problems
Not all clashes are equally important. Some might be major issues that could affect the cost, schedule, or safety of the project, while others might be less critical. Prioritize the most important clashes first, so you can address the biggest problems before tackling the smaller ones. This keeps the project moving smoothly and efficiently.
5. Make Sure Your Models Are Accurate
For clash detection to work, the models used must be accurate. If the models are wrong or incomplete, it could lead to false alarms (finding problems that aren’t there) or missing real issues. Always make sure the models are detailed and up-to-date to avoid these mistakes.
Conclusion
Clash Detection plays a crucial role in ensuring the success of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in today’s construction projects. It helps teams identify and fix any conflicts between different parts of the building early on, which is key to saving money, improving teamwork, and raising the quality of the design. By catching issues in the design phase, before construction even begins, teams can be sure they’re not facing any major problems down the road. As construction projects become more complex, the need for effective Clash Detection will only become more important. This makes it an essential tool for ensuring that projects are completed successfully and smoothly.
